ChatGPT vs Gemini vs Claude: The Best LLM Subscription You Should Buy

One is amazing (I upgraded to the highest tier Sub). One is Forgettable. The Last is a Waste of Money.

Every month, the Chocolate Milk Cult reaches over a million Builders, Startup Founders, Investors, Policy Makers, Leaders, and more. If you’d like to meet other members of our community, please fill out this contact form here (I will never sell your data nor will I make intros w/o your explicit permission)- https://forms.gle/Pi1pGLuS1FmzXoLr6

---

This article is co-written by my foster monkey- Floop- who refused to get off my lap while I was writing this article.

I got him last week, where I was largely indoors working on the Iqidis release. Today I was out b/c NY Tech Week. Looks like he’s decided I’m not allowed to leave the house now.

The question I hear most isn’t “Which AI is best?”—it’s “Which LLM subscription won’t burn my budget?”

You don’t care about benchmarks or marketing hype; you need an AI tab that delivers solid work and doesn’t disrupt your workflow.

I've thrown hundreds of actual tasks at these things: complex research, first-draft generation, visual data requests, the works. I've stress-tested the usual suspects – GPT, Gemini, Claude – plus a few you've thankfully never had to suffer through.

What follows is a straightforward look at where each one excels, where it breaks, and when it’s worth switching. No benchmarks, no affiliate codes—just enough detail to choose the right subscription and move on. After analyzing all of this, we’ll end with a discussion on what this tells us about each of these companies and where they’re headed next.

I have so much to say about this NUMBA 1 BULLSHIT.

PS- This is a review of the Web Apps ONLY. Not the APIs. So, factors like Claude’s excellence with Claude Code, Gemini 2.0 Flash Lite’s insane ROI, or 4o’s excellent skill at orchestration will not be considered.

Two major ways that AI can help you work.

For access to this article and all future articles, get a premium subscription below.

Each of these articles takes a long time to research and write, and your premium subscription allows me to deliver the highest quality information to you. If you agree that high-quality work deserves compensation, please consider a premium subscription. We have a flexible subscription plan that lets you pay what you can here.

PS- Many companies have a learning budget that you can expense this newsletter to. You can use the following for an email template to request reimbursement for your subscription.